PestControlLibrary
Menu

Pitch Twig Moth

Retinia comstockiana[7]

The pitch twig moth (Retinia comstockiana, also listed as Petrova comstockiana) is a small native moth whose caterpillar bores into the current year's twigs of pitch pine and Scotch pine. The giveaway is an orange nodule of resin and frass, about 7/8 inch long, on the upper side of the shoot. It is harmless to people. Infested twigs can be girdled and snap off, deforming young and ornamental pines, but the trees are typically not killed. Prune out twigs with nodules; insecticides are often unnecessary where natural enemies are present.[1][2]

Group
Insect
Order
Lepidoptera
Family
Tortricidae
US records
18 states
Sources
7 cited
Updated
2026-11-14
Pitch twig moth (Retinia comstockiana), a small reddish-brown moth mottled with gray, resting with wings folded
Pitch twig moth (Retinia comstockiana), a small reddish-brown moth mottled with gray, resting with wings folded. (c) Jake McCumber, some rights reserved (CC BY) — via iNaturalist, CC BY 4.0
On this page
  1. Identification
  2. Look-alikes
  3. Where it lives
  4. Biology
  5. Damage and signs
  6. Health risk
  7. Control
  8. Where sources disagree
  9. Related profiles
  10. Common questions
  11. Sources

How to identify it

  • A nodule of resin and frass on the upper surface of a current-year twig, averaging 7/8 inch long (1/2 to 1 1/4 inches), dark red-orange on pitch pine and a lighter orange on Scotch pine; winter weathering bleaches the color. Brown, dislodged needles help flag infested twigs.[1]
  • The caterpillar tunnels down through the pith of the twig and overwinters there with its head toward the lower end of the tunnel; when the adult is ready to emerge, the pupa pushes halfway out of the nodule. The Forest Service says the larvae bore into and down the twigs for 3 or 4 inches, with pitch masses forming over the entry holes.[1][3]
  • The adult is reddish-brown with gray mottling and has a wingspread of 14 to 20 mm, according to the Forest Service's 1972 manual Eastern Forest Insects (which uses the name Petrova comstockiana).[3]

Look-alikes

Look-alikeHow to tell them apart
Northern pitch twig mothA close relative that is easily confused with this one. Its hollow, thin-walled pitch blister usually sits at the crotch of two or more shoots rather than on the upper side of a current-year twig, and it takes two years to complete its life cycle, so larvae can be found year round. Its main hosts are jack, lodgepole and Scots pine. The Forest Service, calling it the pitch nodule maker (Petrova albicapitana), says it occurs wherever jack pine grows naturally in North America, also attacks Scotch and lodgepole pines, and has a wingspread of 16 to 23 mm.[1][4][5][3]
Zimmerman pine mothIts larvae tunnel into branch whorls and under bark of Austrian and Scots pines, leaving large masses of pitch on branches and trunks, and the adult is a midsized moth with gray and red-brown, zigzag-marked wings; the pitch twig moth confines itself to small nodules on current-year twigs. The Forest Service says the adult is gray with a wingspread of about 25 to 37 mm and forewings mottled with zigzag red and gray lines, and that in the North the larvae feed under the bark of limbs and trunks while adults lay eggs at wound edges, on resin masses, in bark crevices or on terminal buds.[6][1][3]

Where it lives

Eastern United States, mainly on hard pines; pitch pine is the main host and Scotch pine is also attacked, red pine only occasionally and lightly when growing near infested pitch pine. GBIF records come mostly from Massachusetts, with others from Alabama, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, New Jersey, Vermont, North Carolina and other eastern states. A 1943 study put the flight period on Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard at about June 19 to July 22. The Forest Service gives its range as Maine to North Carolina and west into the Central States, on the hard pines, with pitch pine preferred in the Midwest.[2][1][3]

US map: public records from 18 states since 1990 (GBIF).

Biology and life cycle

Moths fly in May and June. The eggs are tiny, circular and yellow when first laid. In Ohio, caterpillars were present by June and fed at the bases of the needles for one to two weeks before boring into the twig. The Forest Service likewise says eggs are laid on twigs during May and June in Ohio.[1][3]

Caterpillars molt at least once before boring into the twig. Resin leaking from the feeding site forms the nodule, which the caterpillar works to enlarge with its mouthparts, moving resin, frass and silk. At least five larval instars may occur, though this is not known for certain.[1]

Partly grown caterpillars overwinter head-down in the pith tunnel under the pitch mass, resume feeding by early April in Ohio, cut an exit tunnel and pupate inside the nodule for four to five weeks from the end of April; adults appear by May.[1]

There is one generation a year. UMass notes a history of confusion over a possible second generation, which may occur in the unstudied southern part of the range. The Forest Service also gives one generation per year.[1][3]

Fun fact: Charles Fernald named the species in 1879 for Professor J. Henry Comstock, who collected the first specimens from pitch pine at Ithaca, New York.[1]

Damage and signs

  • Infested twigs may be partly or completely girdled and are more prone to breakage; damaged twigs break off and deform the tree. Twigs that survive often take three to four years to resume normal growth. Twigs under 1/8 inch in diameter are not attacked. The Forest Service likewise says damaged twigs break off, deforming infested trees.[1][3]
  • Host trees are typically not killed, but at high populations the loss of current-season twigs can be economically important, and nursery stock has historically been affected. In forests nodules are rarely found below 4 feet, while on ornamental trees they occur at any height.[1]

Health risk

Neither source mentions any effect on people; this is a pest of pine twigs.[1]

Control

Prevention

Keep pines vigorous and plant them on suitable sites: vigorously growing twigs are less susceptible and can survive up to three caterpillars. Watch for young larvae at the needle bases by mid-June and for nodules on the current season's twigs afterward.[1]

UMass notes that chemical control may not be necessary, especially on forest trees where natural enemies such as the wasp Agathis pini are present.[1]

Traps and physical control

Prune out and destroy infested twigs showing pitch nodules in the terminals.[1]

Biological control

The braconid wasp Agathis pini has been a major control factor; it was a significant mortality factor in forest stands in the Ohio study but was absent from ornamental sites. Hyssopus thymus kills up to 7 percent of caterpillars by late summer, and Calliephialtes comstockii and Glypta varipes are also recorded parasitoids. The Forest Service also calls Agathis pini a major factor in control.[1][3]

Pesticides

UMass lists acephate, bifenthrin (against larvae), chlorantraniliprole, cyantraniliprole, emamectin benzoate and permethrin as active ingredients labeled in Massachusetts; apply after bloom to protect pollinators.[1]

Where sources disagree

Name and family: UMass files it under Petrova (formerly Retinia) and calls it a clearwing moth, while iNaturalist and GBIF use Retinia comstockiana in the leafroller family Tortricidae.[1][7][2]

Flight period: UMass monitoring guidance gives May through June, but the 1943 island study it cites found moths flying from about June 19 to July 22.[1]

Northern pitch twig moth hosts: UMass says the northern species is known from lodgepole and jack pines, while Natural Resources Canada and Michigan State list Scots pine as a main host too.[1][5][4]

Spring timing: UMass says overwintered caterpillars resume feeding by early April in Ohio, while the Forest Service's 1972 manual says development resumes in May, with pupation under the pitch mass.[1][3]

Common questions

What is the orange blob on the tip of my pitch pine twig?
A pitch twig moth nodule: resin that leaked from the caterpillar's feeding, mixed with frass, on the upper side of a current-year twig, usually about 7/8 inch long.[1]
Will it kill the tree?
Typically not. The twig may girdle and break off, deforming the tree, but the sources describe the trees themselves as not killed.[1]
How is it different from the northern pitch twig moth?
The two are easily confused, but the northern pitch twig moth is known from lodgepole and jack pines, while this species attacks the current year's twigs of pitch and Scotch pine.[1]
Should I spray my pines?
Usually not. Pruning out twigs with nodules and keeping trees vigorous are the first steps, and UMass says chemical control may not be needed where natural enemies are present. If you do treat, UMass lists permethrin and emamectin benzoate among active ingredients labeled for landscape use in Massachusetts; apply after bloom to protect pollinators.[1]

Sources

  1. UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program, University of Massachusetts Amherst, “Petrova (formerly Retinia) comstockiana, Pitch Twig Moth, Insect & Mite Guide (Professional Guide for IPM in Trees and Shrubs).” www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/publications-resources/insect-mite-guide/petrova-formerly-retinia-comstockiana (accessed 2026-11-12)
  2. Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF), “Retinia comstockiana: occurrence records.” www.gbif.org/species/1738909 (accessed 2026-11-12). State and country counts from the GBIF occurrence API, read 2026-11-12.
  3. USDA Forest Service, “Eastern Forest Insects, Miscellaneous Publication 1175 (W. L. Baker, February 1972; scanned copy).” archive.org/details/easternforestins1175bake (accessed 2026-11-14). Scanned copy of the USDA Forest Service publication on the Internet Archive; text read from the archive.org full-text (djvu.txt) file.
  4. Michigan State University Extension (archive copy in the MSU Libraries extension archive), “Diagnosing Shoot-Boring Insects of Pines (NCR 528).” archive.lib.msu.edu/DMC/extension_publications/NCR528/NCR528.PDF (accessed 2026-11-12)
  5. Natural Resources Canada, Trees, insects and diseases of Canada's forests, “Northern pitch twig moth.” tidcf.nrcan.gc.ca/en/insects/factsheet/11152 (accessed 2026-11-12)
  6. University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture, “Zimmerman Pine Moth (XHT1164).” hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zimmerman-pine-moth/ (accessed 2026-11-12)
  7. iNaturalist, “Retinia comstockiana taxon page (order and family).” www.inaturalist.org/taxa/50274 (accessed 2026-11-12)

Updated 2026-11-14. Built from sourced records. Spot an error? Tell us.