
On this page
How to identify it
- Utah State gives the aphids as about 1/13 inch long, pale green, covered in a waxy film and with or without wings. Colorado State describes these Pemphigus gall aphids as roughly 2 mm long and pale green with a dark thorax, with wingless forms seen more often than winged ones. Mississippi State describes the aphids on brassica roots as tiny and pale yellow.[1][2][3]
- The easiest sign is the gall: a round, swollen, hollow gall on a leaf stem with the aphids inside. Colorado State calls it marble-sized and Mississippi State gives it as about 3/4 to 1 inch across; when the aphids have developed wings, a horizontal slit opens to let them out.[1][2][3]
- On the roots of cabbage-family plants, colonies are marked by white wax produced by the nymphs; Mississippi State describes it as white, cottony material on turnip roots.[2][3]
Look-alikes
| Look-alike | How to tell them apart |
|---|---|
| Vagabond gall aphid | Its galls form at the ends of cottonwood and aspen branches, where feeding at the growing buds turns leaf tissue into a dense, irregular, bladder-like mass. The galls turn brown and dry and are most noticeable after leaf fall, rather than sitting as round swellings on the leaf stems.[4][5][1] |
| Poplar budgall mite | Microscopic mites make woody, cauliflower-like galls on the buds instead of round galls on the leaf stems.[6] |
Where it lives
Utah State and Colorado State cover it among the gall makers of cottonwoods, poplars and aspens. Mississippi State describes it in Mississippi on eastern cottonwood (Populus deltoides) and on the roots of turnip, cabbage and other brassicas, including brassica weeds.[1][2][3]
Biology and life cycle
In Utah State's and Colorado State's accounts, eggs overwinter in old galls or bark crevices and hatch in spring as the leaves expand. Each young nymph feeds on a developing leaf stem, and the gall grows up around it.[1][2]
Inside the gall the aphid reproduces without mating. In late June or July its offspring develop wings, the gall splits open, and the winged aphids fly to cabbage-family plants, where they colonize the roots and produce several generations of females through the rest of the summer.[2][1]
At the end of summer, winged aphids fly back to poplars and produce small, mouthless males and females. The males die soon after mating, and each mated female lays a single egg and then dies.[2][1]
Mississippi State describes a different calendar: females reproduce without mating on brassica roots through the winter, and in early spring winged females fly to cottonwoods, where they give birth to males and females in bark crevices. Each mated female produces a single egg, and the aphids that hatch crawl to the twig tips and start the petiole galls. Winged aphids leave the galls in late summer and early fall for brassica roots.[3]
Damage and signs
- Both the nymphs and the adults feed, but the galls have little effect on the health of cottonwoods, poplars and aspens; the damage is mainly aesthetic.[1]
- During the root phase they feed on cabbage-family plants. Colorado State treats them as a pest to manage in those crops. Mississippi State says heavy infestations can stunt cabbage and other brassicas and the cottony wax is sometimes seen as a contaminant on turnip roots, but they are not normally a serious problem and treatment is not usually required.[2][3]
Health risk
It is a sap-feeding aphid of trees and cabbage-family roots. Utah State, Colorado State and Mississippi State describe it only as a plant pest; none of them mentions bites, stings or any effect on people or pets.[1][2][3]
Control
Prevention
For trees, Utah State's advice is to tolerate the galls and keep the trees healthy and free of stress. Proper watering and fertilizing that keep plants growing vigorously can offset some of the feeding injury.[1][2]
For brassica crops, planting date matters. Mississippi State says one of the best options for commercial plantings is to delay fall planting until after the female aphids have flown from cottonwoods, and that spring plantings are not attacked. Colorado State likewise says heavy infestations are more likely on crops planted before the fall migration.[3][2]
Pesticides
If you do treat a tree, Utah State suggests horticultural oil on the overwintering eggs in spring before budbreak, or a systemic neonicotinoid in spring. Once galls have formed, cover sprays won't work.[1]
Colorado State suggests insecticides only when aphid numbers pass acceptable levels and quick control is needed, and favors selective, often systemic products that spare beneficial insects and last longer. Systemics are especially useful late in the season on cabbage-family crops, whose plant structure shelters aphids from contact sprays. Rotate modes of action, because aphids can quickly develop resistance.[2]
Where the sources disagree
Seasonal calendar: Colorado State and Utah State have eggs overwintering on poplars, the aphids leaving the galls around midsummer (late June or July, per Colorado State), and a return to poplars at the end of summer; Mississippi State has the aphids on brassica roots through fall and winter and flying to cottonwoods in early spring.[2][1][3]
When they move to crops: Colorado State's life history says late June or July, but its management advice speaks of aphids moving to cruciferous crops in the fall, as Mississippi State does.[2][3]
Where eggs are laid: Utah State says in old galls or bark crevices; Mississippi State says males and females are born in bark crevices on cottonwood in spring and each female produces a single egg.[1][3]
Color: Utah State and Colorado State describe pale green aphids; Mississippi State describes the root-dwelling aphids as pale yellow.[1][2][3]
Pest status on crops: Colorado State discusses insecticides for cruciferous crops; Mississippi State says treatment is not usually required.[2][3]
Common questions
- What are the round green balls on my cottonwood's leaf stems?
- Round, marble-sized galls on the leaf stems are typical of the poplar petiolegall aphid. Each one holds aphids that started feeding there in spring, and they do little harm to the tree.[1][2]
- Do these aphids also feed on garden cabbage?
- Yes, on the roots. Colorado State shows an infestation on cabbage roots, with the nymphs producing a lot of white wax, and Mississippi State, which calls it the cabbage root aphid, finds it on turnip, cabbage and other brassica roots. Mississippi State says it is not normally a serious problem in gardens.[2][3]
- Is it too late to spray once I see galls?
- Yes. Cover sprays don't work once galls have formed. Utah State's options are horticultural oil on the overwintering eggs before budbreak or a systemic neonicotinoid in spring, and because the galls do little harm, it also advises simply tolerating them.[1]
Sources
- Utah State University Extension, Integrated Pest Management, “Petiolegall and Vagabond Gall Aphids (Ornamental Pest Guide).” extension.usu.edu/planthealth/ipm/ornamental-pest-guide/arthopods/aphids-adelgids/petiolegall-vagabond-gall-aphids.php (accessed 2026-11-13)
- Colorado State University, Department of Agricultural Biology, “Insect and mite galls.” agsci.colostate.edu/agbio/ipm-pests/insect-and-mite-galls/ (accessed 2026-11-13)
- Mississippi State University Extension Service, “Cabbage Root Aphid/Poplar Petiolegall Aphid (Bug's Eye View, Vol. 5, No. 2, 2019; Blake Layton).” extension.msstate.edu/newsletters/bugs-eye-view/2019/cabbage-root-aphidpoplar-petiolegall-aphid-vol-5-no2 (accessed 2026-11-13)
- University of Wyoming Agricultural Experiment Station, “Poplar vagabond gall aphid fact sheet, B-1041 (T. Noma, J. K. Wangberg and M. J. Brewer, August 1996).” www.wyoextension.org/agpubs/pubs/B1041.pdf (accessed 2026-11-13)
- Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources, Division of Forestry, “Poplar vagabond aphid (Forestry News, L. Williams, July 2017).” forestrynews.blogs.govdelivery.com/2017/07/27/poplar-vagabond-aphid/ (accessed 2026-11-13)
- Utah State University Extension, Integrated Pest Management, “Poplar Budgall Mite (Ornamental Pest Guide).” extension.usu.edu/planthealth/ipm/ornamental-pest-guide/arthopods/mites/poplar-budgall-mite.php (accessed 2026-11-13)
- Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF), “Pemphigus populitransversus Riley, 1879 (GBIF Backbone Taxonomy).” api.gbif.org/v1/species/2069955 (accessed 2026-11-13)
- iNaturalist, “Pemphigus populitransversus taxon page (order and family).” www.inaturalist.org/taxa/179801 (accessed 2026-11-08)