The short answer
- Verdict: No evidence. Ask Extension found no data-based science for using banana peels on roses, and recommends composting kitchen waste before using it in the garden.[1]
- NC State Extension says banana peels decompose slowly in the soil, attracting pests and potentially harboring mold.[2]
- What works instead: a strong spray of water, natural enemies, reflective mulch for vegetables, and insecticidal soaps or oils.[3][4]
What the research found
Answering a gardener's question about sprinkling chopped peels or peel tea under rose bushes, an Ask Extension expert said many websites and blogs recommend it, but found no data-based science for this practice.[1]
NC State Extension's Beaufort County Center reviewed the buried-banana-peel hack and found the peels decompose slowly in the soil, attract pests and may harbor mold, and their nutrients are not in a form plants can use right away.[2]
Why people think it works
The claim usually rides on banana peels as a fertilizer: a peel is said to add potassium and phosphorus to the soil as it decomposes. NC State agrees the peels do contain nutrients, but advises composting them instead.[2]
What works instead
Knock aphids off sturdy plants with a strong spray of water. UC IPM says most dislodged aphids won't be able to return, and their honeydew is washed off too.[3]
Silver-colored reflective mulches repel invading aphids in summer squash, melon and other susceptible vegetables, reducing their numbers on seedlings and small plants, UC IPM says.[3]
If insecticides are needed, UC IPM says insecticidal soaps and oils are the best choices for most situations and are safer to use when children and pets may be present.[3]
The University of Minnesota says insecticidal soap, horticultural oil and pyrethrins can be effective at controlling aphids.[4]
Common questions
Sources
- Ask Extension (Cooperative Extension System), “Banana peels and rose bushes (expert answer #793043).” ask.extension.org/kb/faq.php?id=793043 (accessed 2026-11-12)
- NC State Extension, Beaufort County Center, “Gardening Hacks or Hype? Debunking Viral Tips With Science and Common Sense (May 2025).” beaufort.ces.ncsu.edu/2025/05/gardening-hacks-or-hype-debunking-viral-tips-with-science-and-common-sense/ (accessed 2026-11-12)
- University of California Statewide IPM Program, “Aphids (Pest Notes, Home and Landscape).” ipm.ucanr.edu/home-and-landscape/aphids/ (accessed 2026-11-12)
- University of Minnesota Extension, “Aphids in home yards and gardens.” extension.umn.edu/yard-and-garden-insects/aphids (accessed 2026-11-12)