The short answer
- Verdict: Partly. The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station lists bars of soap among homemade repellents that work in areas of low to moderate deer densities.[1]
- Repellents reduce deer browsing, but control is inconsistent and they do not eliminate damage altogether, the Station says.[1]
- For mice and rats, the Internet Center for Wildlife Damage Management says chemical repellents are seldom practical solutions for mouse infestations.[4]
- What works instead: fencing for deer, and sealing entry points plus trapping for mice.[1][4]
What the research found
The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station says earlier research there and elsewhere showed that repellents reduce deer browsing in orchards, nurseries and Christmas tree plantations, but control is inconsistent.[1]
In the Station's own guidance, strong-smelling bars of soap are hung on the outer ends of branches, on a string passed through a hole drilled in the soap, in the same manner as hair bags, which are spaced no more than 3 feet apart.[1]
NC State Extension lists fragrant soap hung on the outer branches of trees every 3 feet, and says each bar protects an area of 1 square yard.[2]
Smell alone is not always enough. In a Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station test, bobcat and coyote urine significantly reduced deer browsing of Japanese yews, while urine of humans and cottontail rabbits did not reduce damage.[3]
Why people think it works
In places with few deer, homemade repellents such as hair and bar soap do reduce damage, so the trick often seems to work. The Connecticut Station says these repellents work in areas of low to moderate deer densities, and that repellent control is inconsistent.[1]
Irish Spring for mice and rats
ICWDM says rodents find some types of tastes and odors objectionable, but chemical repellents are seldom practical solutions for resolving infestations of mice.[4]
What works instead
For deer, the Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station lists fencing and other physical barriers, deer-resistant plant species, scare devices and repellents. A combination of odor- and taste-based repellents, alternated over time, can often help.[1]
NC State Extension says repellents are most effective if applied before deer become accustomed to foraging on garden plants, and warns that using mothballs to manage deer is illegal and potentially dangerous.[2]
For mice, ICWDM lists sanitation, rodent-proof construction that seals openings larger than ¼ inch, and reducing the population with traps.[4]
Common questions
- Does it have to be Irish Spring?
- The Connecticut and NC State guidance describes strong-smelling or fragrant bar soap in general, not one brand.[1][2]
- Do mothballs keep deer away?
- NC State Extension says using mothballs to manage deer is illegal and potentially dangerous, and children and pets can be poisoned by eating them.[2]
Sources
- Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station, “Controlling Deer Damage in Your Garden (fact sheet).” portal.ct.gov/-/media/caes/documents/publications/fact_sheets/controllingdeerpdf.pdf (accessed 2026-11-12)
- NC State Extension, “Management Strategies to Minimize Deer Damage in the Landscape.” gardening.ces.ncsu.edu/integrated-pest-management/wildlife-5/management-strategies-to-minimize-deer-damage-in-the-landscape (accessed 2026-11-12)
- Journal of Chemical Ecology (Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station), via PubMed, “Swihart RK, Pignatello JJ, Mattina MJ (1991), Aversive responses of white-tailed deer, Odocoileus virginianus, to predator urines. J Chem Ecol 17(4):767-777.” pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24258921/ (accessed 2026-11-12)
- Internet Center for Wildlife Damage Management, “House Mouse Damage Prevention and Control Methods.” icwdm.org/species/rodents/house-mice/house-mouse-damage-prevention-and-control-methods/ (accessed 2026-11-12)