The short answer
- Verdict for eggshells: No evidence. In the RHS trial, crushed eggshells laid in a complete circle around lettuces made no difference to the damage.[1]
- Verdict for copper: Partly. UC IPM and Utah State Extension recommend copper barriers, but the University of Minnesota warns that not all copper strips or tape sold for slug control is wide enough to be effective.[2][3][4]
- Copper tape also made no difference in the RHS trial, although other experiments by the same researcher hinted that copper tape could be effective.[1]
- What works instead: remove hiding places, handpick at night, trap under boards, and use iron phosphate baits if needed.[2]
What the research found
For its Gastropod Barriers project, RHS entomologist Hayley Jones grew 108 lettuces in a series of nine patio pots and nine raised beds and monitored them for six weeks.[1]
The barriers tested were crushed eggshells, pine bark mulch, copper tape, sharp horticultural grit and wool pellets. She found no difference in the damage sustained by the protected lettuces and the ones left without barriers.[1]
The RHS concluded that these barriers can be unreliable and ineffective, while noting that existing lab studies have shown some of the barriers work.[1]
Extension advice on copper is more positive. UC IPM says barriers made with copper flashing and screen are the easiest to maintain, and recommends a 4- to 6-inch-wide band of copper, buried an inch below the soil or attached around the edge of a raised bed.[2]
Utah State University says mesh copper screens or sheeting 8 inches wide make effective barriers, but barriers are not lethal and divert the pests to other nearby vegetation.[3]
The University of Minnesota says copper barriers are most practical for small gardens and containers, and must be wide enough to accommodate the whole slug.[4]
Why people think it works
Copper has been shown to deter slugs by reacting with their mucous, which gives slugs something like an electrical shock, the University of Minnesota says.[4]
Eggshells are meant to work like other sharp, scratchy materials. Wisconsin Extension lists regular applications of an abrasive, sharp-edged material such as diatomaceous earth, gravel or sand to deter slug movement.[5]
But Minnesota says even diatomaceous earth has little effect when it absorbs moisture and is generally not an effective slug deterrent.[4]
If you try copper
UC IPM says copper foil or tape will repel snails until it becomes tarnished, and tarnished bands can be cleaned with a vinegar solution.[2]
Make sure the soil inside a banded planter box is snail-free first. UC IPM says to hand-pick any snails and slugs left inside after applying the band.[2]
Barriers only work if slugs and snails have other desirable places to feed or hide, Utah State says.[3]
Minnesota cautions that the sharp edges of some barrier products may cause safety problems, especially for young children.[4]
What works instead
UC IPM says management requires vigilance and a combination of practices: eliminating moisture and hiding spots, trapping, exclusion and handpicking.[2]
Remove shady, cool hiding places such as weeds, wooden boards, stones or flowerpots, and reduce moisture by switching to drip irrigation or running sprinklers in the morning rather than later in the day.[2]
Handpick at night, or build a trap from a board raised off the ground by 1-inch runners and scrape off the slugs that collect under it daily. Beer traps buried at ground level also catch them.[2]
If you use bait, UC IPM says iron phosphate baits are safer for use around dogs, children and wildlife, while metaldehyde baits can be poisonous to dogs and birds.[2]
Common questions
- Do crushed eggshells hurt slugs?
- The RHS trial found no difference in damage between lettuces ringed with crushed eggshells and lettuces with no barrier.[1]
- How wide does copper tape need to be?
- UC IPM recommends a 4- to 6-inch-wide band of copper; Utah State says screens or sheeting 8 inches wide. Minnesota says many tapes sold are not wide enough.[2][3][4]
- Are eggshells useful in the garden at all?
- This page covers slugs only. For slugs, UC IPM's combination of hiding-spot removal, trapping, handpicking and iron phosphate bait is the tested approach.[2]
Sources
- Royal Horticultural Society (RHS Science), “How to stop slugs and snails: what works? (Gastropod Barriers project, Hayley Jones).” rhs.org.uk/science/articles/stop-slugs-and-snails (accessed 2026-11-12)
- University of California Statewide IPM Program, “Snails and Slugs (Pest Notes, Home and Landscape).” ipm.ucanr.edu/home-and-landscape/snails-and-slugs/ (accessed 2026-11-12)
- Utah State University Extension, “Controlling Slugs and Snails in Utah.” extension.usu.edu/pests/research/slugs-snails (accessed 2026-11-12)
- University of Minnesota Extension, “Slugs in home gardens.” extension.umn.edu/yard-and-garden-insects/slugs (accessed 2026-11-12)
- University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture), “Slugs.” hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/slugs/ (accessed 2026-11-12)